hp检查是什么| 大哥是什么生肖| 什么动物是站着睡觉的| 抬举征阳性是什么意思| 楠字五行属什么| 肾阴虚吃什么中成药| 不明原因发烧挂什么科| 经常拉肚子是什么原因| 透析是什么意思| 健康证是什么样的| grace什么意思中文| 小便黄是什么原因引起的| 抗药性是什么意思| 为什么会得胆结石| 维生素d补什么| 赤脚医生是什么意思| 梨子什么时候成熟| 老年人腿无力是什么原因导致的| 彪是什么动物| 伤口发炎化脓用什么药| 3911农药主要治什么| 30岁是什么之年| 耳鸣是什么原因造成的| 刷脂是什么意思| 艾灸后放屁多是什么原因| 血清载脂蛋白b偏高是什么意思| 油嘴滑舌指什么生肖| 母亲属虎孩子属什么好| 人为什么会得阑尾炎| 为什么会长囊肿| 洛神花是什么花| 乳酸阈值是什么意思| 冷战什么意思| 霸凌是什么意思| 囊性灶是什么意思| 脾脏切除后有什么影响| 界代表什么生肖| 什么是宫外孕| 梦见刀是什么意思| x是什么牌子的衣服| 声带白斑是什么病| 漫不经心是什么意思| 眼睛经常充血是什么原因引起的| 低血压对身体有什么影响| 脂蛋白高吃什么药能降下来| 积劳成疾的疾是什么意思| 口腔溃疡看什么科| 驻外大使是什么级别| 舌系带短会有什么影响| 古人的婚礼在什么时候举行| 肾阳虚是什么意思| 常吃南瓜有什么好处和坏处| 蚊子咬了涂什么| 749局是什么| 草木皆兵指什么生肖| 本科和专科是什么意思| 应届生是什么意思| 天荒地老是什么生肖| 诛心是什么意思| 什么什么不周| 拍拖是什么意思| 择日是什么意思| 什么是胶体| 仙人掌煎鸡蛋治什么病| 不言而喻是什么意思| 就请你给我多一点点时间是什么歌| 1964年是什么命| 什么是机械表| 宫颈筛查是检查什么| 食神生财是什么意思| 五行缺水是什么意思| 朱砂有什么功效| hbcab阳性是什么意思| 球蛋白偏高是什么原因| 前羽念什么| 甜醋是什么醋| 小孩子长白头发是什么原因| 嗓子突然哑了是什么原因引起的| 十点半是什么时辰| 减脂晚上吃什么好| 手指发麻是什么原因| 六块钱的麻辣烫是什么意思| 肝硬化吃什么水果好| 大侠是什么意思| 腱鞘炎用什么药能治好| 三生石是什么意思| 单亲是什么意思| 盐水是什么| 什么洗面奶最好用| 刑警是干什么的| 为什么种牙那么贵| 沙棘原浆什么人不能喝| 热狗是什么| 什么目寸光成语| 男人有泪痣代表什么| 百合花什么时候种植| 呼吸不过来要喘大气是什么情况| 检查是否怀孕挂什么科| 缺钾有什么症状| 脱发严重是什么原因| 考试什么的都去死吧歌曲| 撤侨是什么意思| 6月适合种什么菜| 吃brunch是什么意思啊| 小儿疳积是什么症状| 什么茶减肥效果好| sodium是什么意思| 蜂王浆什么味道| 感冒了能吃什么水果| 什么饼不能吃| 三叉神经痛吃什么药效果好| 徐长卿是什么药| 生理期什么意思| 立加羽念什么| 女兔配什么属相最好| 香港什么东西值得买| 鳄鱼的天敌是什么动物| 牙神经拔了对牙齿有什么影响| 评头论足什么意思| 三月三是什么星座| 肝脏是什么功能| 迪丽热巴的全名叫什么| 非洲人说什么语言| 专科是什么| hpv16有什么症状| 尿检潜血是什么意思| 文科女生学什么专业就业前景好| 罗字五行属什么| 胃糜烂吃什么药最好| 什么是芝士| 黑醋是什么醋| 白细胞中性粒细胞高是什么原因| 肚脐左下方疼是什么原因| 丹五行属性是什么| 高校自主招生是什么意思| 减肥喝什么茶最好最快| 33年属什么生肖| 属猴男和什么属相最配| 运动出汗多是什么原因| 用什么泡脚好| 二尖瓣关闭不全是什么意思| temp是什么文件夹| 阳痿是什么原因造成的| 仔细的什么| 仙女座是什么星座| 血小板偏低有什么危害| 梦见和死去的人说话是什么意思| m样症状是什么| 维生素c吃多了有什么危害| 清热去火吃什么药| 尿频尿急尿不尽挂什么科| 骆驼是什么品牌| 什么在千里| 10.30什么星座| 瘤变是什么意思| 本是什么意思| 胆固醇高应注意什么| 为什么总是放屁| 女宝胶囊的作用和功效是什么| 大同有什么好玩的地方| 首发是什么意思| 大便出血吃什么药| 老鹰茶是什么茶| 类风湿不能吃什么东西| 上海有什么好玩的地方适合小孩子| 老年人适合吃什么水果| 66是什么意思| 节气是什么意思| 甲醛中毒吃什么药| 男人阳气不足有什么症状| 狗狗吃什么| 掉以轻心是什么意思| 血包是什么意思| 议论纷纷是什么意思| 纳字五行属什么| 苏州有什么好玩的| 什么时候降温| 少阳证是什么意思| 绿字五行属什么| 睡醒后口干口苦是什么原因| 什么是支气管扩张| 五心烦热失眠手脚心发热吃什么药| 一什么手套| 阴虚有什么症状| 盘根是什么| 脾气虚吃什么中成药| 病毒性感冒什么症状| 下呼吸道感染吃什么药| 生发吃什么食物好| 7月1日是什么节| 推辞是什么意思| 什么样的情况下需要做肠镜| 脾虚湿气重喝什么茶| 楞头青是什么意思| 子宫肌瘤吃什么能消除| 倾注是什么意思| 脸上发红是什么原因| 年轮稀疏的一面是什么方向| 为什么说成也萧何败也萧何| 吃什么可以减肥肚子| 藜麦是什么| 保险属于什么行业| 办理护照需要什么资料| who是什么意思| 动物的尾巴有什么用处| 水变成冰为什么体积变大| 化胡为佛是什么意思| 煎牛排用什么锅最好| 10月16日是什么星座| 饮食男女是什么意思| 补蛋白吃什么最好| 吃什么补精养肾| 刘三姐是什么生肖| 可遇不可求是什么意思| 菠菜什么时候种最合适| mary是什么意思| 头孢是治什么的| 急性胰腺炎是什么病| 翻墙软件是什么| 止咳平喘什么药最有效| 大同有什么好吃的| 尿酸高看什么科| 骨折补钙吃什么钙片好| 马刺是什么| 氨糖是什么| 1987年出生属什么生肖| 熬夜伤什么| 虫介念什么| 肾阴虚吃什么| 风调雨顺的下联是什么| 二月七号是什么星座| 一九七七年属什么生肖| 新陈代谢慢吃什么药| her是什么意思| 蛇吃什么| 为什么耳朵总是嗡嗡响| 巨蟹女和什么座最配对| 肝功能异常是什么| 螃蟹为什么吐泡泡| 为什么肾阳虚很难恢复| 左腰疼痛是什么原因男性| 孝喘吃什么药好| 何首乌长什么样| 成佛是什么意思| 窈窕淑女是什么意思| 秦国是现在的什么地方| 灌肠用什么水| 乳清是什么| 肺炎后遗症有什么症状| 葫芦的寓意是什么| 芜湖有什么大学| 摸金是什么意思| 水浒传主要讲了什么| 颈椎病用什么枕头最好| 韭菜籽配什么壮阳最猛| 七月二十是什么星座| mpe是什么意思| 超滤是什么意思| 吃完香蕉不能吃什么| 甲亢病是什么病| 想飞上天和太阳肩并肩是什么歌| 素土是什么| 月经喝酒有什么影响| 切除子宫有什么影响| 百度

Unpacking the amendment

Published October 27, 2024
The writer is president of the Pakistan-based think tank Pildat.
The writer is president of the Pakistan-based think tank Pildat.

SUCCESSIVE governments and parliaments in Pakistan have appeared obsessed with constitutional amendments related to the judiciary, especially the superior judiciary. Our parliament has so far passed 23 constitutional amendments.

Formally these are counted as 26 despite the fact that three (the ninth constitutional amendment of 1985, the 11th of 1989 and the 15th of 1998) were introduced but never passed. Out of these 23 amendments, a majority of 13 or 56 per cent have to do entirely or partly with the judiciary. Eight amendments almost exclusively deal with the judiciary, while the remaining five are a mixed bag with a number of subjects including the judiciary. In stark contrast, India’s parliament has passed 106 constitutional amendments so far and only 11 or a little over 10pc deal with the judiciary.

These amendments passed in Pakistan can be viewed in the context of the ever-present power tussle between the executive and the judiciary. Since the executive is a subset of parliament in a parliamentary democracy practised in Pakistan, and a majority of parliamentarians are associated with the executive, parliament and its committees do not exercise any real oversight of the executive. The majority ruling party or parties expect their parliamentarians to go soft on their government during the proceedings of the plenary and standing committees; almost always, the members seem to oblige. In such a scenario, the only other institution which can and should independently hold the federal and provincial governments to account is the judiciary, especially the high courts and the Supreme Court. Most governments are, therefore, keen on finding a way to blunt the judicial weapon of accountability — hence, such a large percentage of judiciary-related constitutional amendments in Pakistan.

To be fair, however, it has not always been the judiciary on the receiving end; there are times when the judiciary also apparently ‘encroaches’ on the turfs of parliament and the executive. This description was used by Asif Saeed Khosa, a former chief justice of Pakistan, who repeatedly pleaded for a ‘grand dialogue’ to check encroachment by the judiciary, parliament, the executive, the military and intelligence agencies in each other’s domain.

It was the Supreme Court which endorsed the death sentence of former prime minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto in 1979. It was also the same apex court, of course comprising different judges, which declared in 2024 that Mr Bhutto was not given a fair trial by the Lahore High Court and the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court also sacked two elected prime ministers of Pakistan; Syed Yousuf Raza Gilani in 2011 and Nawaz Sharif in 2017 on grounds largely believed to be less than legitimate. Chief justice Saqib Nisar’s Supreme Court went on to disqualify Nawaz Sharif for life and to hold him ineligible to head his party the PML-N, although there was no such provision in the Constitution. Justice Umar Ata Bandial’s Supreme Court grossly misinterpreted the constitutional provision of Article 63-A about the defection of parliamentarians. All such judgments had to be later reversed. The Supreme Court is also criticised for upholding four grossly unconstitutional acts of dismissal of elected governments and military takeover.

Most governments want to find a way to blunt the judicial weapon of accountability.

This is the background against which the 26th Amendment was proposed and eventually passed by parliament. The bill was first introduced in the Senate on Sunday, Oct 20, and the hectic process of going through the first, second and third readings continued till a little before midnight. The process concluded in the National Assembly in the early hours of Monday, Oct 21. The president assented to the law and the Act of Parliament was notified in the Gazette of Pakistan the same day.

The bill could be partly categorised as ‘reactive’ to the real or perceived ‘encroachment’ by the judiciary and partly ‘preventive’ to forestall possible future acts of the judiciary, which may threaten the existence of the current government and National Assembly, with some ministers saying on media that they expected such action by a section of the judiciary after the retirement of chief justice Qazi Faez Isa on Oct 25, 2024. This explains the indecent haste with which the package of constitutional amendments was rushed through the two houses of parliament.

The 26th Amendment has either amended, substituted, or added 25 articles and one schedule of the Constitution out of which only nine articles deal with subjects other than the judiciary. Three of the amended articles deal with religious provisions and may be categorised as ‘riders’ using the American slang for amendments incorporated to win the support of more legislators and political parties for the package. These three amendments were proposed by Maulana Fazalur Rehman’s JUI-F.

The most important changes introduced in the Constitution through the amendment include the appointment of the Supreme Court chief justice through a 12-member parliamentary committee, instead of the senior-most judge of the court automatically becoming the top judge; the retirement of the chief justice at the age of 65 or on completing a three-year term, whichever occurs first; the introduction of constitutional benches in the apex court to be constituted by the Judicial Commission from time to time and in the high courts, subject to the approval of the respective provincial assemblies; reconstitution of the 13-member Judicial Commission after merging the erstwhile parliamentary committee in it; an annual performance evaluation of high court judges by the Judicial Commission; provision for a secretariat headed by a secretary for the commission; and lowering the minimum age to qualify for becoming a high court judge from 45 to 40 years.

These amendments, no doubt, increase the influence of the legislature and the executive in key aspects of the judiciary. Will the legislative and executive branches use the newly acquired powers maturely and strictly on the basis of merit, or allow personal and political considerations to colour their judgments? The jury is out on this question.

The writer is president of the Pakistan-based think tank Pildat.

X: @ABMPildat

Published in Dawn, October 27th, 2024

Opinion

Editorial

Hybrid ruin
Updated 03 Aug, 2025

Hybrid ruin

The PTI may be suffering, but it still wants the blessing of its tormentors more than the sympathy of their other victims.
No advantage
03 Aug, 2025

No advantage

THE new agreement between Pakistan and the US, heralded as a ‘strategic’ breakthrough in their trade and...
Starvation politics
03 Aug, 2025

Starvation politics

THE visit of US envoy Steve Witkoff to Gaza’s aid corridors underlines how broken the West’s humanitarian...
TTP footholds
Updated 02 Aug, 2025

TTP footholds

While terrorism issue must be taken up with Afghanistan, local responses should ensure thorough CT actions so KP doesn't suffer endlessly.
USC’s closure
02 Aug, 2025

USC’s closure

TO many, the closure of the state-owned utility stores highlights the failure of successive governments to reform...
Going nowhere
02 Aug, 2025

Going nowhere

THE Sukkur-Hyderabad Motorway seems to be paved with broken promises and not much else. No matter how many times the...
心率低吃什么药好 闪亮的什么 什么情况需要打破伤风 72年属鼠是什么命 降龙十八掌最后一掌叫什么
愤青是什么意思 副业做什么比较好 杨玉环属什么生肖 经常打飞机有什么危害 鼻窦炎有什么特效药
跳梁小丑是什么生肖 妹妹的女儿叫什么 肝不好吃什么水果 四维彩超和大排畸有什么区别 太监是什么生肖
反差萌是什么意思 气加山念什么 essential是什么意思 什么叫强直性脊柱炎 面部提升做什么项目最好
双离合是什么意思hcv8jop9ns4r.cn 怨念是什么意思hcv9jop1ns4r.cn 低血压挂什么科hcv9jop0ns0r.cn 吃什么药能让月经推迟hcv7jop6ns7r.cn 液金是什么travellingsim.com
l是什么字dajiketang.com 年金是什么cl108k.com 青蛙是什么weuuu.com 狮子座上升星座是什么zsyouku.com 月经肚子疼是什么原因hcv8jop6ns4r.cn
羊肉馅饺子放什么菜hcv8jop2ns6r.cn 吐信子是什么意思啊hcv8jop6ns1r.cn 乌豆是什么hebeidezhi.com 玉鸟吃什么饲料好hcv9jop3ns5r.cn 睡眠障碍吃什么药最好hcv9jop0ns7r.cn
c2驾照可以开什么车hcv9jop8ns3r.cn 梦见鼻子出血是什么意思hcv8jop8ns0r.cn 什么的枝干liaochangning.com 沉香是什么hkuteam.com 吃什么食物能降低胆固醇hcv8jop6ns6r.cn
百度