淋巴是什么引起的| 脚掌麻木是什么原因| 哺乳期妈妈感冒了可以吃什么药| 宿便什么意思| 西洋菜是什么菜| 6.7是什么星座| 96是什么意思| 惺惺相惜什么意思| 为什么会得霉菌感染| 卫生局是什么单位| 气管疼什么原因引起的| 花胶和什么煲汤最适合| 争奇斗艳是什么意思| 05年属鸡的是什么命| 亲吻是什么感觉| 油性记号笔用什么能擦掉| 鹭鸶是什么动物| 什么天空填动词| 清明节是什么时候| 脸部肿胀是什么原因| 小便憋不住尿裤子是什么情况| 无痛人流和普通人流有什么区别| 感冒吃什么食物好得快| 一个王一个番读什么| 脚麻吃什么药| 养殖业什么最赚钱农村| 眼球出血是什么原因引起的| 属羊的是什么星座| 前列腺液是什么颜色| 红糖水什么时候喝最好| 两棵树是什么牌子| 合肥以前叫什么| 张良和刘邦是什么关系| 肝昏迷是什么症状| 梦见自己头发长长了是什么意思| 儿童用什么牙膏最好可以保护牙齿| 娃娃鱼吃什么| 红薯什么时候传入中国| 酚氨咖敏片的别名叫什么| 尿频尿黄是什么原因| 2月25日是什么星座| 女生肚子疼是什么原因| 梦见办酒席是什么意思| 心慌意乱是什么意思| 兵马未动粮草先行是什么意思| 男人喜欢什么姿势| 3ph是什么意思| 醋酸生育酚是什么东西| 天珠有什么作用与功效| 脂肪浸润是什么意思| 月经期间适合吃什么水果| 麒麟飞到北极会变成什么| 信任是什么意思| 海狗是什么动物| 自变量是什么| 喝茶有什么好处| 包皮龟头炎用什么药| 今年72岁属什么生肖| 怀孕初期能吃什么不能吃什么| 天秤座是什么星象| 壁虎属于什么类动物| 橡木色是什么颜色| 广藿香是什么味道| 舌头疼是什么原因| 参乌健脑胶囊适合什么人吃| 3.7号是什么星座| 平菇不能和什么一起吃| 头发爱出油是什么原因| 胯骨在什么位置| 三焦是什么| 阴阳先生是干什么的| 老人嗜睡是什么征兆| 水逆退散什么意思| 罗森是什么| 二氧化硅是什么氧化物| 梦见别人打架是什么意思| 石足念什么| 什么是竖式计算| 氧氟沙星和诺氟沙星有什么区别| ia是什么意思| 吃的少还胖什么原因| 67年的羊是什么命| 养胃早餐吃什么好| 结石是什么原因引起的| 一直以来是什么意思| 不可或缺是什么意思| 老鼠长什么样子图片| 拿乔是什么意思| 为什么一睡觉就做梦| 拔智齿后可以吃什么| 什么能美白皮肤而且效果快| 梦见蚂蚁是什么预兆| 乌豆是什么| 女命正财代表什么| 脚上有青筋是什么原因| 66年出生属什么生肖| 上厕所出血是什么原因| 手腕疼痛挂什么科| 吃高血压药有什么副作用| 吃什么有奶| 保质期是什么意思| 月经期间喝酒有什么危害| 吕布为什么叫三姓家奴| 梦见自己生了个儿子是什么意思| 低压高会引起什么后果| 梦到跟人吵架是什么意思| 做活检前要注意什么| 五官指的是什么| 六味地黄丸有什么功效| 梦见莲藕是什么意思| 风疹病毒是什么病| 什么是双向抑郁| 鸡头米是什么东西| 10月23号是什么星座| 瓷娃娃什么意思| 大红袍是什么茶| 玉米是什么时候传入中国的| 日语为什么怎么说| 梦见自己的车丢了是什么意思| 风的孩子叫什么| 喉咙发炎吃什么消炎药| 什么叫周围神经病| 何弃疗是什么意思| 脚脖子粗是什么原因| 眉毛长痘是什么原因| 宁字属于五行属什么| 空气炸锅可以做什么| 知我者非你也什么意思| 梦见自己开车是什么意思| 梦到自己孩子死了是什么征兆| 鸟屎掉手上有什么预兆| 光绪帝叫什么名字| 便血鲜红色无疼痛是什么原因| 婴儿肥是什么意思| 口腔扁平苔藓吃什么药好得快| 时隔是什么意思| 中国第一长洞是什么| mfd是什么意思| 蛤蚧是什么动物| 劳动法什么时候实施的| 脂肪肝中医叫什么名字| 一进门见到什么植物好| 为什么生理期过后最容易掉秤| 兔子吃什么蔬菜| 什么叫感性的女人| 什么粥养胃| 点灯是什么意思| 香港代购什么东西好| 部长是什么职位| 口腔炎吃什么药| 上大厕拉出血是什么原因| 什么津乐道| 耳朵烧是什么原因| 塞浦路斯说什么语言| 电饼铛什么牌子好| gln是什么氨基酸| 吃燕窝有什么好处| 最里面的牙齿叫什么| 黄疸是什么| 男性阴囊瘙痒是什么病| 腋下异味挂什么科| 牙龈充血是什么原因| 速写男装属于什么档次| 看眼睛挂什么科| 女人骨质疏松吃什么最好| 扒灰什么意思| 桔子什么时候成熟| 吹水是什么意思| heineken是什么啤酒| hardly什么意思| 吃葡萄皮有什么好处| 白醋加盐洗脸有什么好处| 慢性前列腺炎有什么症状| 夜尿多吃什么药效果好| 猪大肠炒什么好吃| 手麻木吃什么药好| 什么是素数| 微商是什么意思| 为什么会得子宫腺肌症| 麻黄碱是什么| 蜜蜡和琥珀有什么区别| 1988年出生是什么命| 龘读什么| 什么是混合痔| 缅甸的首都叫什么名字| 尿酸高适合吃什么菜| 青光眼是什么原因引起的| 3.2号是什么星座| 班门弄斧什么意思| 蚊子怕什么颜色| 扮猪吃老虎什么意思| 甲胎蛋白偏高是什么原因| 气滞血瘀吃什么食物好| 一什么凤冠| 身心俱疲是什么意思| 尿素氮偏高是什么意思| 炖牛肉放什么调料好吃| 妊娠囊是什么意思| 心意已决是什么意思| 地龙是什么生肖| 讲师是什么职称| 高血压中医叫什么| 马桶对着卫生间门有什么不好| 动容什么意思| 什么发型适合自己| ia是什么意思| 唯小人与女子难养也什么意思| 红鸡蛋用什么染| 蜂蜜喝了有什么好处| 糖尿病能吃什么水果| 阳痿早泄是什么原因| 心律不齐是什么病| 灰指甲有什么特效药可以治好| 急性子是什么意思| 乙肝核心抗体高是什么意思| 牙龈一直出血是什么原因| 汪峰是什么星座| 什么叫换手率| 备孕喝豆浆有什么好处| 什么的小虾| 深渊是什么意思| 宽宽的什么填空| 什么是正颌手术| 做梦被杀了是什么征兆| 相得益彰什么意思| 李健为什么退出水木年华| 薛之谦属什么生肖| 避火图是什么| 月经血量少是什么原因| 燕窝有什么功效和作用| 放是什么偏旁| 93年是什么年| 网球大满贯什么意思| 贵州菜属于什么菜系| 萨德是什么意思| 舌苔发白是什么病| 舌头起泡吃什么药好| 大便带血丝是什么原因| 开什么节什么的成语| 佑字五行属什么| 丑五行属什么| 孕妇早上吃什么早餐好| 什么叫早泄| 重庆沱茶属于什么茶| 2023年是属什么生肖| dazzle是什么牌子| 吃什么回奶| 蛇盘疮吃什么药好得快| 湿罗音是什么意思| 鼻塞是什么原因| 空囊是什么原因造成的| 钓鲤鱼用什么饵料| 她将是你的新娘是什么歌| 全麦面包是什么意思| 珠地棉是什么面料| 很困但是睡不着是什么原因| 世界上笔画最多的字是什么字| fizz是什么意思| 尚清是什么意思| 铁杵是什么| 奇点是什么意思| 吃完海鲜不能吃什么水果| 飞机联程票是什么意思| 眉中间有竖纹代表什么| 百度

A matter of form

Published February 25, 2024
The writer is president of the Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development And Transparency.
The writer is president of the Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development And Transparency.

AT the centre of the raging controversy over the Feb 8 election results are two forms prescribed in Election Rules, 2017: Form-45 is the Result of the [vote] Count prepared by the presiding officer at each polling station and Form-47 is the Provisional Consolidated Statement of results of the vote count of all polling stations in a constituency prepared by the concerned Returning Officer (RO) before including the received postal ballots in the count.

These two and some other associated forms like the Ballot Paper Account of each polling station (Form-46), Consolidated Statement of the Results of the Count Furnished by the Presiding Officers including the count of postal ballots (Form-48) and Final Consolidated Result (Form-49) constitute the backbone of the system of electoral transparency guaranteed by Elections Act, 2017.

Primarily, there are three pillars which sustain the integrity of the electoral process (especially on polling day) operations in Pakistan. The first pillar is the correctness of the information recorded in Forms 45 to 49. If there are flaws in the basic information contained in Form-45 and the obvious errors and omissions such as an incorrect total are not checked by the RO at the time of receiving Form-45, the errors, in all probability, will be carried through, leading to incorrect results for the constituency.

Although both the presiding officer and senior-most assistant presiding officer at each polling station are required to sign, affix their thumb impressions, and record their CNIC numbers, certifying that they have checked and verified the completed form, many Form-45s generally contain errors, and, in some cases, the signatures of the officers are missing. The law also requires that the completed Form-45 also be signed by the polling agents of the candidates but in the 2018 election, 90 per cent of the forms uploaded on the ECP website did not contain the signature of any polling agent, raising questions about the credibility of the forms. Such scrutiny of Form-45s in the 2024 election is yet to be undertaken as the forms have not been uploaded on the ECP website yet.

There are three pillars which sustain the integrity of polling day operations.

The second pillar of poll integrity is sharing information with all candidates and political parties through their polling and election agents, and the media and public at large soon thereafter. In order to ensure complete transparency, an authenticated copy of Form-45 has to be handed to the polling agent of each candidate according to Elections Act, 2017. In fact, the law also requires that a copy of Form-45 be pasted outside each polling station for the information of the public.

Unlike 2018 election, when the most common complaint on polling day was that polling agents had been excluded from vote counting at the polling stations and quite a few of them were reportedly not given signed copies of Form-45, not many such complaints were heard in election 2024. The most complaints regarding polling day this time do not appear to be related to polling stations where most polling agents seem to have received the completed Form-45. This time the bulk of complaints related to the operations in the ROs’ office where reportedly many candidates and their agents were not allowed to be present during the consolidation process to prepare Form-47, and resultantly, many candidates reported wide divergences between the number of votes recorded in Form-45 and the ones subsequently entered in Form-47.

A major controversy revolves round the alleged discrepancy between these two forms. Many candidates declared to have lost the election have complained that the sum total of the votes obtained by them and recorded on Form-45 does not tally with the total votes shown in Form-47. These complaints raise serious questions about both the correctness of information contained in Form-47 and the transparency of the consolidation process threatening the credibility of the polls.

The third critical pillar supporting the edifice of polling day integrity is the timeliness of sharing the information contained in these forms and the declaration of results. Timeliness is not necessarily the swiftness with which the results are declared; it is living up to the promised legal timeline. Some countries like India have a system of counting votes and declaring election results days and weeks after polling day, and that works fine for them without compromising the credibility of polls because their election commission fulfils the legal timelines. Pakistan has its own specific poll timelines built into the election laws and rules, and violating such legal provisions has serious implications for the credibility of elections.

The proviso in Section 13(3) of the Elections Act clearly delineates the timeline of declaration of provisional election results, according to which each RO is bound to compile the complete provisional results by 2 a.m. on the day immediately following polling day. If, for any reason, this is not possible, the RO “shall send the complete provisional results as soon as compiled but not later than 10 a.m.” Since almost all of the 859 returning officers violated the timeline and the complete provisional results were not declared even after a lapse of 48 hours beyond the final deadline, serious questions about the integrity of election are being raised.

Another important aspect of the system of transparency and timeliness of declaring results is clearly spelled out in Section 95(8) and (10) of the Elections Act. These legal provisions demand that “the Commission shall within 14 days from the date of the poll, publish the documents on its website”. The documents referred to in the law are Forms 45, 46, 48 and 49. As the deadline of 14 days expired on Feb 22 without the ECP uploading the documents on its website, another serious legal lapse has occurred, which appears to have further undermined the perception of integrity and credibility of the electoral process. It seems that the ECP will have to do a lot of explaining in order to counter such negative perceptions.

The writer is president of the Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development And Transparency.

president@pildat.org

X: @ABMPildat

Published in Dawn, February 25th, 2024

Opinion

Editorial

Hybrid ruin
Updated 03 Aug, 2025

Hybrid ruin

The PTI may be suffering, but it still wants the blessing of its tormentors more than the sympathy of their other victims.
No advantage
03 Aug, 2025

No advantage

THE new agreement between Pakistan and the US, heralded as a ‘strategic’ breakthrough in their trade and...
Starvation politics
03 Aug, 2025

Starvation politics

THE visit of US envoy Steve Witkoff to Gaza’s aid corridors underlines how broken the West’s humanitarian...
TTP footholds
Updated 02 Aug, 2025

TTP footholds

While terrorism issue must be taken up with Afghanistan, local responses should ensure thorough CT actions so KP doesn't suffer endlessly.
USC’s closure
02 Aug, 2025

USC’s closure

TO many, the closure of the state-owned utility stores highlights the failure of successive governments to reform...
Going nowhere
02 Aug, 2025

Going nowhere

THE Sukkur-Hyderabad Motorway seems to be paved with broken promises and not much else. No matter how many times the...
脑补是什么意思 梦到自行车丢了是什么意思 生长发育挂什么科 泡面吃多了有什么危害 嗓子哑吃什么药
什么是力量训练 菠菜不能与什么一起吃 贫血都有什么症状 中央党校什么级别 细胞学说揭示了什么
1为什么读yao 糖尿病人吃什么主食 非萎缩性胃炎吃什么药 有里面没有两横是什么字 肉桂茶适合什么人喝
驰骋沙场百战威是什么生肖 子宫内膜炎用什么药效果好 口腔溃疡是缺少什么维生素 臭氧是什么味道 磬是什么乐器
商业保险报销需要什么材料hcv8jop9ns8r.cn 氢氧化钙是什么东西hcv9jop7ns1r.cn 什么情况下血压会升高hcv8jop0ns6r.cn 榴莲不能跟什么一起吃hcv9jop3ns0r.cn 就此别过是什么意思hcv9jop3ns5r.cn
六月十一号是什么星座hcv8jop3ns2r.cn 灌肠什么感觉hcv7jop7ns2r.cn 唯爱是什么意思creativexi.com 肝囊肿是什么病hcv8jop2ns5r.cn 小妾是什么意思hcv8jop0ns8r.cn
补体c4偏低是什么意思hcv8jop5ns8r.cn 吃什么水果对心脏好hcv8jop9ns9r.cn 左胳膊发麻是什么原因hcv8jop3ns2r.cn 梦见笑是什么意思hcv8jop6ns3r.cn 社保缴费基数什么意思hcv8jop9ns9r.cn
巳时属什么生肖hcv8jop5ns3r.cn 省检察长什么级别hcv8jop6ns8r.cn 血常规异常是什么意思hcv8jop0ns2r.cn 口巴读什么hcv9jop2ns3r.cn 两女 一杯是什么hcv8jop8ns1r.cn
百度